
Wylder Windham
Best for families or groups who want on-site activities (pool, saunas, bikes, games) and easy access to Windham Mountain.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Wylder Windham is a family-friendly, activity-focused Catskills resort spread across roughly 20 acres beside the Batavia Kill. The Amelia is a small, polished inn in Hudson for travelers who want an intimate downtown stay with short walks to galleries and restaurants.
Updated · about 22 miles apart (≈35 km)

Best for families or groups who want on-site activities (pool, saunas, bikes, games) and easy access to Windham Mountain.

Best for travelers who want a compact, walkable Hudson base with a highly rated small-inn experience and easy access to downtown galleries and restaurants.
When Wylder Windham wins: choose Wylder if you want more on-site recreational options, multiple room types for families or groups, and resort-style grounds for outdoor play and events.
When The Amelia wins: pick The Amelia when your priority is an intimate Hudson location, short walks to the opera house and town nightlife, and a quiet, residential inn with polished common areas.
Bottom line: Wylder is a spread-out, activity-rich Catskills resort built for families and multi-day outdoor plans; The Amelia is a compact Hudson inn that suits adults or couples looking to stay in town and explore on foot.
| Category | Wylder Windham | The Amelia |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Resort-style, active, family-focused across 20 acres | Small, polished downtown inn with residential charm |
| Location | Windham village, beside the Batavia Kill, minutes from Windham Mountain | 339 Allen St, Hudson — in the town center within a short walk to cultural sites |
| Size (rooms) | About 108–110 rooms across multiple buildings | 8 guestrooms |
| Who can stay / ages | All ages welcome (family-friendly) | Children 11 and younger are not permitted (12+) |
| Pools | Seasonally heated outdoor pool (included via resort fee); listings note two pool areas + hot tub | Seasonal outdoor pool with sun loungers and pool umbrella (shared; fence around pool) |
| Restaurants & bars | Babblers Restaurant, Bar & Bakery on site (dinner, bakery/cafe); bar with limited late hours | No full-service on-site restaurant listed; complimentary self-serve breakfast and shared kitchen amenities |
| Wellness / spa | On-site wood-fired barrel saunas; nearby Windham Spa for treatments (off-site) | No on-site spa; 'health or beauty spa nearby' listed |
| Known for | Large grounds with lots of on-property activities, family programming, and event spaces | Highly rated small inn in the heart of Hudson with residential common rooms (library, fireplace) |
| Parking & access | Free self-parking on site | Free self parking (uncovered, limited spaces); no staffed front desk — self check-in access code |
| Breakfast | Cooked-to-order breakfast available for a surcharge; Babblers Bakery for grab-and-go | Complimentary free self-serve breakfast daily (4:00 AM–1:00 PM) |
Wylder Windham sits on roughly 20 acres beside the Batavia Kill, minutes from Windham Mountain.
Choose Wylder if you want easy access to mountain recreation and wide outdoor grounds.
The Amelia is in central Hudson on Allen Street within short walking distance of cultural sites.
Choose The Amelia for a walkable Hudson stay centered on town life and galleries.
Wylder Windham offers about 108–110 rooms and suites across a Victorian main house, cottages, and lodges.
Wylder suits families or groups who need varied room sizes and suite choices.
The Amelia has a very small inventory: 8 guestrooms listed, including Single Room and Studio Suite.
The Amelia is best for travelers who prefer a small-inn scale and simple room types.
Wylder’s on-site dining is centered on Babblers Restaurant, Bar & Bakery.
If you want a full-service hotel restaurant and a casual bakery on site, Wylder provides both.
The Amelia offers complimentary self-serve breakfast; there is no full-service restaurant listed.
The Amelia suits guests who plan to eat locally in Hudson rather than rely on hotel dining.
Wylder features a seasonally heated outdoor pool and other outdoor amenities across the grounds.
Wylder’s pool is part of a broader package of outdoor activities aimed at families and active guests.
The Amelia has a seasonal outdoor pool and poolside loungers; the pool area is fenced.
The Amelia’s pool is small and geared to a quieter, adult-focused stay in town.
Wylder’s wellness offering centers on wood-fired barrel saunas and outdoor relaxation.
Wylder mixes rustic sauna-based wellness with outdoor evening programming rather than a formal spa.
The Amelia does not list an on-site spa; it has a fireplace lobby and library for low-key evenings.
The Amelia is quieter on-site but places you within walking distance of Hudson’s evening scene.

Wylder — large grounds, kids’ activities, family-sized rooms and on-site recreation.

The Amelia — in central Hudson within easy walking distance of galleries, theaters, and restaurants.

Wylder — full-service Babblers Restaurant, bar, and an on-site bakery/cafe.

The Amelia — only eight rooms and residential common spaces for a low-key stay.
Wylder Windham — it’s explicitly family-friendly with kids’ programming, family room options, and many on-site activities.
The Amelia — it’s in downtown Hudson with cultural sites and eateries within a short walk.
Yes. Both list a seasonal outdoor pool; Wylder’s pool is part of a larger resort program, while The Amelia’s is a small, shared hotel pool.
Wylder has wood-fired barrel saunas on site and refers guests off-site to The Windham Spa for treatments; The Amelia lists a nearby health/beauty spa rather than an on-site spa.
The supplier listing states children 11 years old and younger are not permitted at the property (i.e., the inn effectively restricts younger children).
Explore how Wylder Windham stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·